This post may contain affiliate links, including those from Amazon Associates. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more about our affiliate policy.
There’s something so satisfying about walking into a thrift store, spotting a dusty, overlooked item, and imagining what it could become.
I’ve always loved the treasure-hunt feeling of thrifting, but what makes it even more exciting is when those finds can be transformed into creative crafts that actually sell online.
If you’ve ever thought about starting a small side hustle with handmade items but don’t want to spend a fortune on supplies, thrift flipping is the perfect solution.
It’s budget-friendly, sustainable, and brimming with creative potential. Best of all, these projects don’t require advanced crafting skills, just a little imagination, some basic tools, and a willingness to experiment.
Here are 10 easy thrifted craft ideas you can start making and selling right away.
1. Painted Mason Jar Storage
Mason jars are one of the easiest thrifted finds to transform, and they always sell well because they’re practical and decorative.
- Start with clean jars. Lightly sand them so paint adheres better.
- Spray with chalk paint, sea-glass spray, or matte acrylics in cozy colors like cream, sage, or charcoal.
- Add embellishments such as twine wraps, stenciled words, or decorative knobs on the lids.
- Use as bathroom organizers, kitchen storage, or flower vases.
These jars are inexpensive to make and can be customized endlessly—great for bulk orders or seasonal sales.
2. Vintage Tart Tin Magnets or Ornaments
Tart tins, jello molds, and other small vintage kitchen pieces are easy to find at thrift stores. With a little creativity, they become charming magnets or holiday ornaments.
- Wash and dry the tins thoroughly.
- For magnets, hot-glue magnet backs. For ornaments, attach ribbon or twine loops.
- Fill the inside with pressed flowers, tiny illustrations, or faux greenery.
- Seal with clear resin or Mod Podge to protect.
These have a nostalgic, handmade feel that makes them irresistible as gifts or holiday décor.
3. Rustic Picture Frame Art
Thrift stores are full of frames just waiting for a second life. With a fresh coat of paint and a little imagination, they can be turned into best-selling home décor.
- Sand and repaint frames with chalk or milk paint for a rustic look.
- Insert pressed flowers, dried leaves, or decorative scrapbook paper as the artwork.
- For a farmhouse vibe, stencil words like “Home” or “Gather” onto burlap fabric and frame it.
These sell especially well in online marketplaces where farmhouse and rustic décor is always trending.
4. Upcycled Silverware Jewelry
Old forks and spoons may not look glamorous in the thrift store bin, but they can be turned into unique pieces of jewelry or decorative markers.
- Select vintage silver-plated utensils—they bend easier than stainless steel.
- Use pliers to shape handles into rings, cuffs, or pendants.
- Add jump rings and chains for necklaces.
- For garden markers, stamp herb names onto spoon bowls.
This is a little more hands-on, but the result feels one-of-a-kind and highly giftable.
5. Decorative Spindle Candle Holders
Wooden spindles, chair legs, or old lamp bases are some of the most underrated thrift store finds. With just a little paint, they transform into charming candle holders.
- Detach the spindle or base and sand it smooth.
- Paint with chalk paint, then distress lightly for rustic character.
- Drill or carve a shallow hole in the top to fit taper candles.
- Seal with wax or a matte finish for durability.
They have that vintage-meets-modern vibe buyers love, and no two pieces look the same.
6. Hand-Painted Wood Signs
Wood scraps and pallets often end up discarded, but they’re perfect for handmade signs. Personalized wood signs are one of the most popular categories on Etsy, making this a profitable craft.
- Cut or sand down thrifted boards into workable sizes.
- Paint the surface with a base coat in white, black, or soft gray.
- Use stencils or freehand lettering to paint messages like “Welcome” or “Bless This Home.”
- Distress edges slightly for a farmhouse touch.
The beauty is in their simplicity—shoppers love anything that feels heartfelt and handmade.
7. Tiered Teacup Tray
Mismatched china and vintage plates can be thrifted for pennies, and they make beautiful tiered trays with just a bit of assembly.
- Gather a few cups, saucers, or small plates in coordinating styles.
- Use a sturdy dowel or metal rod as the central support.
- Stack and glue with E6000 adhesive for durability.
- Finish with felt pads on the bottom to prevent scratching tables.
These trays are perfect for jewelry, snacks, or holiday displays. They look boutique-worthy but are incredibly inexpensive to make.
8. Nail Polish Marbled Coasters
This trend is inexpensive, eye-catching, and easy to DIY. All you need are thrifted ceramic tiles and old nail polish.
- Fill a shallow tray with water.
- Drizzle in nail polish and swirl with a toothpick to create a marbled effect.
- Dip tiles face-down into the design and pull them out carefully.
- Seal with a waterproof spray for durability.
- Attach cork or felt backing.
Each coaster is one-of-a-kind, and sets of 4 or 6 make excellent seller bundles.
9. Thrifted Trinket Tray Makeovers
Trinket trays, ashtrays, or small bowls often go unnoticed on thrift store shelves, but they’re perfect for quick flips.
- Choose sturdy trays in ceramic, wood, or metal.
- Clean thoroughly and sand if needed.
- Paint, decoupage with patterned paper, or gild with metallic foil.
- Seal with Mod Podge or polyurethane for durability.
These make great vanity or coffee table accents, and buyers love their luxe, handmade look.
10. Marbled Tile Accessories
Like coasters, thrifted tiles can be given a new life as functional décor. The key is in presentation.
- Use larger tiles as spoon rests, candle bases, or mini serving boards.
- Paint or marble them with the same nail polish swirl method.
- Seal and package them attractively for online sales.
Affordable to make and easy to ship, these projects are ideal if you want to scale up production.
Tips for Selling Thrifted Crafts Online
The beauty of thrifted crafts is how customizable they are. Here are a few ways to maximize your sales:
- Think in sets. Coasters, jars, or magnets sell better in bundles of 3–6.
- Highlight sustainability. Eco-conscious buyers love knowing their purchase supports reuse.
- Style your photos. Natural light, clean backdrops, and staging with plants or books makes a huge difference.
- Price fairly. Factor in both your time and the unique character of upcycled pieces—you’re not just selling materials, you’re selling creativity.
Wrapping It Up
Thrift flipping is one of the most fun and budget-friendly ways to start making money with crafts. You don’t need fancy tools or a huge workshop, just a few thrift store finds and a little creativity.
These 10 easy craft ideas are approachable for beginners, yet polished enough to sell in online shops or at local markets.
The next time you head into a thrift store, look at the shelves a little differently. That jar, tray, or stack of old china might just be your next best-selling craft.
